We must build our future primarily out of the past … and out of the people whose lives have been interwoven into our history.
James A. Blaisdell in a letter to Harvey Mudd in 1927
CGU 100: Our Origin Story
Chapters
More chapters coming soon
Introduction
Chapter 1
CGU owes its existence to the resolve of a visionary founder, the support of a modest but renowned philanthropist, and the dealmaking of a lawyer who shunned the spotlight but became immortalized on campus. Its history is inseparable from the City of Claremont, whose trajectory would be far different if not for a vacant hotel, ample shrubland, and a train depot. It is steeped in tenacity, gamesmanship, constant reinvention, and world-changing success.
CGU's history is unlike any other university's, and it has never been told this way before.
Claremont and what grew into The Claremont Colleges began to emerge in the 1890s when this photo was taken from Cucamonga Avenue, known today as Arrow Highway. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
Claremont Colleges [the earliest name for what became CGU]must become a separate, free-standing institution, or wither and die.
Malcolm Douglass, Phoenix in Academe
The name and official seal have changed many times since CGU's founding as Claremont Colleges (not to be confused with The Claremont Colleges consortium). The Greek lamps represented the individual colleges. For the initial proposal in 1928, Blaisdell suggested, "The shield should be surmounted by one large lamp, which will represent the central organization … Claremont Colleges," with the two smaller lamps representing Pomona College and the newly formed Scripps College. The symbol atop the shield evolved to a torch, the flame of which symbolizes CGU today.
1928
1928 Seal
1929
1929 Seal
1944
1944 Seal
1959
1959 Seal
1961
1961 Seal
1962
1962 Seal
1967
1967 Seal
1999
1999 Seal
James A. Blaisdell envisioned a consortium of colleges with leaders working "in a spirit of democratic comradeship." His optimism soon proved ill-founded, however, in large part because the consortium lacked a formal, written agreement about who should do what. Claremont Colleges (so named because it administered the consortium's shared services and facilities) depended on faculty from Pomona and Scripps to teach its graduate courses, but there was continual friction over course assignments, priorities, and finance.
Over time, Claremont Colleges hired its own graduate faculty and thrived, reinventing itself as needed. The theme of reinvention can be seen through the multiple name changes attempting to reconcile the disparate functions of centralized services and graduate education. In 2000, these functions were formally divided into two institutions, Claremont Graduate University and The Claremont Colleges Services. Though Blaisdell later drew criticism for his credulous belief that college leaders would always be guided by goodwill, his ambition and vision were never questioned.
[We] will need educational opportunities far beyond anything we now have. … Instead of one great, undifferentiated university, we might have a group of institutions divided into small colleges — somewhat on the Oxford type.
James A. Blaisdell in a letter to Ellen Browning Scripps in 1923
James A. Blaisdell never shied away from big ideas. Not long after he arrived in 1910 to resuscitate a financially struggling Pomona College, he recognized an unprecedented yet fleeting opportunity. Claremont, a nascent college town in an undeveloped region, could become an intellectual powerhouse, shaping the West and beyond.
Just as New York served as a gateway to Europe, Blaisdell saw Los Angeles as a future bridge to Asia and Latin America. He envisioned Claremont Colleges as a "University of the Pacific" and dedicated his life to making Claremont a leading intellectual center where graduate work would be paramount to attracting and retaining top talent.
Blaisdell found a kindred spirit and perfect partner in Ellen Browning Scripps, a businesswoman and philanthropist — but more than that, a relentless seeker of knowledge and a champion of progress and empowerment. "I am deeply interested in what President Blaisdell is planning," she said. "It is a forward-looking project that I think means much for education." Together, they would make history.
A rare photo of James A. Blaisdell from his time at Beloit College, where he was a Professor of Biblical Literature and Ancient Oriental History, as well as library director. [Blaisdell's The Story of a Life: an Autobiography]
Ellen Browning Scripps from her newspaper days in Detroit, where she wrote a popular daily column called "Miss Ellen's Miscellany." [Ella Strong Denison Library]
Nowhere else in this country had such an educational development been achieved or even contemplated.
James A. Blaisdell, The Story of a Life
I have plunged into life, O God,
As a diver into the sea,
Knowing and fearing naught
Save thine old command to me
To grope, and search for the truth,
Hidden wherever it be.
Ellen Browning Scripps' handwritten interpretation of Lily A. Long's "The Diver," one of her favorite poems. [J.C. Harper's Ellen Browning Scripps]
Robert J. Bernard arrived at the Central Pacific Railroad passenger depot in Sacramento on October 14, 1925, to file the articles of incorporation for Claremont Colleges. [California State Railroad Museum Library]
A noble act of faith.
Robert J. Bernard in Frances Bernard Drake's Two Men and an Idea
It was a beautiful day, with the gold dome of the Capitol shining beneficently.
Robert J. Bernard, notes from the Board of Overseers meeting in 1965
October 14
1925
Robert J. Bernard — James A. Blaisdell's protégé and a future CGU president — was on an urgent mission to Sacramento, one that required an overnight train trip to ensure he arrived on time.
He strode toward the secretary of state's office with documents that would officially give birth to Claremont Colleges. "The Group Plan, the first of its kind in the United States, struck fire," Bernard reflected years later.
But why was it so urgent that Claremont Colleges be incorporated on
1887
Early Claremont and Pomona College
Chapter 2
New England idealism and the progressive spirit of the West.
Robert J. Bernard, Two Men and an Idea
The Pomona Land and Water Company created stable water infrastructure in 1883, critical to the development of the area. H.A. Palmer, the co-founder and president, had a personal land investment in North Pomona and convinced the Santa Fe Railway to route their westward expansion through (surprise!) North Pomona and a rustic, unnamed "townsite" south of Indian Hill in which he and his family resided. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
Leaders of the Congregational Church in Southern California spent the first half of the year putting the finishing touches on their plans for "a college of the New England type" that would be grounded in Christian values but non-sectarian and open to both men and women. After vetting numerous locations, they chose 120 acres in North Pomona, named Piedmont Mesa, donated by H.A. Palmer.
They drafted articles of incorporation for their fledgling college and took them to Sacramento, where they were approved on October 14 — 38 years to the day before Bernard's dash to incorporate Claremont Colleges. About the same time, the Pacific Land Improvement Company, a railroad subsidiary based in Boston, was putting the finishing touches on its Claremont Hotel, hoping to cash in on newcomers looking for a place to stay while they scouted the area's land boom.
October 14, 1887
The future of the southwest was beginning to reveal itself, and they foresaw a unique educational development.
Robert J. Bernard, The Case for Claremont
Train tracks are white noise in a modern cityscape, but in the 1800s they breathed life into the dreams of civic leaders, entrepreneurs, and land speculators. Tracks meant transportation, commerce, opportunity, and the chance for quick money. 1887 was a propitious time for Southern California's track-adjacent communities, but as the short-lived boom turned to bust, Pomona College's founders struggled with fundraising to build in Piedmont Mesa. They opened their doors in September 1888 at a makeshift rented cottage in Pomona.
In 1887, the Pacific Land Improvement Company purchased and subdivided 188 acres north of the tracks, and Sante Fe built a makeshift depot to attract buyers. The name Claremont came from the clear view of the mountains and honored one of the speculators who grew up near the New England community of Claremont, New Hampshire. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
A more fortunate spot for such purposes could hardly be imagined.
James A. Blaisdell, Claremont — An Educational Ideal
The Pacific Land Improvement Company created this flier to promote "Claremont the Beautiful," which was marketing speak for desert terrain and swampland covered with sage and heavy undergrowth. The "Hotel Claremont" and artesian wells enticed potential buyers, along with a "sold" declaration on numerous lots. (Get yours before it's too late!) But their plans crumbled as interest fizzled and the hotel was abandoned before serving a single guest. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
January 1889
The sudden economic downturn might have shattered plans for the college if not for the perseverance of its founders and an amazing turn of events. Just hours after the college board laid the cornerstone for the new building at Piedmont Mesa—a symbolic act despite dwindling financial support—the Pacific Land Improvement Company made an unexpected offer:
The college could have the Claremont Hotel and more than 250 nearby lots if it agreed to return a share of the proceeds from the future sale of lots. The board accepted, but retained the name Pomona College because they believed their permanent home was to the west. After moving to Claremont during the Christmas holidays, classes resumed in January in the newly named Claremont Hall, later renamed Sumner Hall in honor of Mary L. Sumner, wife of founding trustee Charles B. Sumner.
Why Pomona College remained in Claremont
Despite the board's intentions, (spoiler alert) Pomona College never returned to Pomona. The Claremont location simply had too much to offer, including proximity to the train station, which for many years remained integral to transportation in the region. It also had all those vacant lots, which meant lower-cost opportunities for expansion. And once the college started growing, more and more members of the college community built homes nearby. After passionate debate, the Piedmont Mesa project was formally abandoned in 1892, with the land and pledges returned to donors.
The Pomona Class of 1895 moved the cornerstone from the abandoned site on Piedmont Mesa to Carnegie Hall on the Claremont campus and carved a motto in Greek that translates to "Not to live but to live well."
Why Claremont became the perfect location
While Blaisdell saw Los Angeles as the gateway to the Pacific, he recognized Claremont as an ideal location for academics. Close enough to benefit from the resources and opportunities of the growing metropolis, yet far enough to provide a serene environment for deep scholarly reflection, Claremont is now known as the City of Trees and PhDs.
Blaisdell, a Wisconsinite, along with the East Coast transplants who made up much of early Claremont's population, greatly appreciated the region's “Greek skies and sunshine.” A promotional booklet titled Indian Hill captured this sentiment, describing Claremont as offering "Adirondack summers, the New England autumn, and the Florida winter in one place."
A 1908 relief map of Southern California illustrates the region's diverse geography and highlights the 158-mile-long figure-eight of the "Kite-Shaped Track." In addition to passenger and freight services, the route was famous for its scenic excursions through orange groves, valleys, and mountain foothills, offering picturesque views advertised under the slogan "No Scene Twice Seen." [New York Public Library]
Pomona in the foreground dwarfs Claremont and nearby citrus groves, with the San Gabriel Mountains looming over both. B.D. Jackson, who started as portrait photographer, captured many images of Southern California. "Views don't talk back," he said, explaining his new focus. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
Furniture was generously donated by the local community and from “as far away as the Eastern seaboard,” transforming the vacant hotel into Pomona College's first proper building. With "thirty-two study and sleeping rooms, recitation rooms, chapel, reception room," and a library for which books "were still to be obtained," it housed everything — classes, offices, student rooms, and social functions — before becoming exclusively a women's dorm in the early 1890s. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
In the new building ... centered the life of the College. Save for a few families who began to settle outside, the whole community life ran on under this one roof.
M. E. Churchill, Pomona College — An Historical Sketch
E.C. Norton served as Pomona College Dean from 1893 to 1926. Among his many accomplishments, he is credited with attempting to grow the first lawn in Claremont. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections.]
Norton was a Renaissance man. The professor of Greek built his own house on Seventh Street when it was barely a dirt road. The property served as a playground for faculty members' children, who would fill the yard and porch stairs. (He admonished them to stay off his lawn.) The house still stands, noticeably remodeled but with its porticos clearly visible. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
An oasis in the desert.
Frank P. Brackett, Granite and Sagebrush
Claremont evolved as a college-centric town, with faculty, students, and families transforming the desert into a community. Citrus cultivation, beginning in 1888, also played a crucial role in Claremont's development. The town's growth revolved around Pomona College, establishing it as a "college with a town" rather than vice versa, fostering an environment conducive to intensive academic pursuits.
Pomona College drives the development of regional infrastructure.
James A. Blaisdell was far from the only visionary leader during Claremont's early years. Cyrus G. Baldwin, the first official president of Pomona College, was instrumental in laying the groundwork — literally — for development in the area. He recognized the potential power that could be harnessed by the water flowing in San Antonio Canyon to the north. Though he had no engineering background, he brought together a team of experts to build the San Antonio Light & Power Company, which he hoped would not only provide electricity to the college but also generate revenue as the region grew.
Long before The Claremont Colleges became an educational powerhouse, they needed an actual powerhouse. Cyrus G. Baldwin led the creation of the first long-distance transmission of hydroelectric power in the nation, the forerunner of Southern California Edison. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
This house on Fifth Street was built in 1888 near what is now Mallows Park by Colonel W.H. Holabird, a Civil War veteran turned real estate agent and land auctioneer for the Pacific Land Improvement Company. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
The Review of Reviews, a progressive magazine founded in the 1890s, highlighted the transformative potential of irrigation in the American West. It predicted small farms would foster a new civilization offering sustainable, community-oriented living that avoided both urban congestion and rural isolation. Small towns could grow around cultural institutions while retaining rural benefits. Claremont in its early years exemplified this vision of community-oriented living.
Pomona College Book Store then vs now
Duvall's on the northeast corner of Yale Avenue and First Street served as Pomona College's first bookstore and the community's general store and pharmacy. O.H. Duvall (Class of 1895) paid his way through school by selling books and stationery in a small room on campus. He later became Claremont's postmaster, a registered pharmacist, and director of the First National Bank of Claremont. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
Claremont in 1893 resembled a prairie town, but homes began springing up all around Pomona College, which created decades of anxiety for James A. Blaisdell as he sought to secure enough land for his vision of the consortium.
Dean Norton
Sumner Hall
The original depot, built in 1887, looks quaint by today's standards, but it was a cookie-cutter, clapboard copy of the stations that Santa Fe Railroad built throughout the West. The depot, where O.H. Duvall served as the first ticket agent (what didn't he do?), was essential to Claremont's growth. The building was replaced in 1927 by the Spanish Colonial Revival style depot that stands today. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections, circa 1906]
I can't understand, sir, how an institution like yours can have reached such substantial growth in so short a time.
Theodore Roosevelt to Pomona College President George Gates in 1903
This historic photo was taken from the west side of Holmes Hall, which was draped in the crimson of Harvard (Roosevelt's alma mater) along with Pomona's blue and white. Crimson bunting, emblazoned with the spirited "Rah Rah Harvard" yell, completed the display. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
May 8, 1903
Based on the many breathless news stories about the event, May 8, 1903, was a momentous day for Claremont. President Theodore Roosevelt, honoring an invitation from Pomona College President George Gates, had come to the campus as part of his eight-week whistlestop tour of 25 states. Well over 6,000 locals, visitors, politicians, business icons, Civil War veterans, and Roughriders came in wagons and carriages, by horse and bicycle, and on foot to see the 26th president, who spoke passionately about education and its impact on life, politics, and humanity.
"It is such a pleasure to be in this college town today. … you are erecting the superstructure of intellectual, moral, and spiritual well-being," Roosevelt said from a platform in front of Parsons Hall. "It was certainly a great day, the most notable in point of importance and popular visitation in the history of Claremont to which all roads seem to lead for the time being," the Pomona Progress reported.
Faculty and Student growth 1888-1908
1888-89
1889-90
1890-91
1891-92
1892-93
1893-94
1894-95
1895-96
1896-97
1897-98
1898-99
1899-00
1900-01
1901-02
1902-03
1903-04
1904-05
1905-06
1906-07
1907-08
Pomona was also a phenomenon in the large proportion of graduates who continued on into graduate study. This last result seemed to me one of the finest testimonies to our educational success.
James A. Blaisdell, The Story of a Life.
https://www.youtube.com/embed/9O6g9ZUlYsY?si=NElYo6DlNc-BAAs2
A Continuing Vision of Greatness, narrated by Ronald Reagan is a short film that highlights the growth of the consortium from its early years to the early 1960s, when it was made.
There is priceless footage of life at Pomona College that "aroused a good deal of interest, due to the humorous appearance of the styles of those days and the obvious development of the campus since that time. … although it was taken less than ten years ago," Secretary of the Faculty William S. Ament quipped in a letter to J.C. Harper in 1927.
More chapters coming soon...
Blaisdell & Scripps Form a Partnership
Chapter 3
Either it was the beginning of a new period or—it was the end.
Frank P. Brackett, Granite and Sagebrush
President George A. Gates is joined by dignitaries and most of the Pomona College community as the cornerstone for Carnegie Library is laid in 1907. Key funding came from the Carnegie Foundation, which also provided a substantial gift to support faculty pensions soon after James A. Blaisdell's arrival in 1910.
January 1909
George A. Gates was at a breaking point. A highly respected scholar and administrator, Gates was beloved by the students at Pomona College, where he had doubled enrollment, expanded the campus, and brought the institution to national prominence in his eight years as president. Jane Addams and Theodore Roosevelt came to speak "chiefly because of President Gates," and Ellen Browning Scripps, taken by his "good humor and charm," visited Pomona College by his invitation in 1908. But despite these accomplishments, one weakness would be his undoing: "I cannot raise money."
The burden of fundraising fell on Gates after Charles B. Sumner suffered a severe nervous breakdown in 1908, three months into leading a campaign to raise $250,000 to save Pomona College (again) from dire financial straits. Despite suffering burnout, in part from not taking a vacation in 20 years, Gates managed to reach almost half of the campaign goal before "broken health and discouragement" forced him to resign and take a six-month trip to Australia and New Zealand to quiet his "troubled nerves." The same kind of stress would almost break Blaisdell 15 years later.
He is the best man for Pomona College there is in America.
Philanthropist D.K. Pearsons, who supported Pomona College and was instrumental in its selection of James A. Blaisdell. [Natalie Joy Stromberg Ward, James A. Blaisdell]
Dignitaries and college presidents from across the country came to Claremont in January 1911 to attend James A. Blaisdell's two-day inauguration ceremony. Blaisdell spoke about Pomona College's destiny to be a major contributor to the future of the region. “The new president is a forceful, convincing speaker, and his inaugural address revealed the sincerity, breadth of vision and strong personality of the man,” Out West Magazine observed.
Summer 1909
Nobody knew Pomona College and what it needed in a president better than C.B. Sumner. After George A. Gates resigned, Sumner traveled to the Pacific Northwest, the Atlantic Seaboard, and the Midwest in search of a new breed of administrator with a higher level of financial acumen. A "superior president." James A. Blaisdell emerged as the standout candidate recommended by multiple sources, including trusted ally D.K. Pearsons, a Chicago real estate mogul who played a crucial philanthropic role in the early development of both Pomona College and Beloit.
Unfamiliar with Pomona College, Blaisdell offered a tepid response to Sumner's initial inquiry. Undeterred, and unbeknownst to Blaisdell, Sumner made a trip to Beloit speak with Blaisdell's professional and personal acquaintances. Convinced that he had found a perfect fit — someone who was a highly regarded educator but had also done a heroic job of raising funds to secure books for his new library — Sumner reached out again. Sensing the opportunity, Blaisdell agreed to make his first-ever trip to the West Coast to visit Claremont. He did some reconnaissance of his own at the University of California, where he was told, "Don't hesitate." His visit to Pomona College was a monumental success, culminating with a speech in which he "electrified the audience and shifted the campus atmosphere from uncertainty to optimism."
Blaisdell's Beloit Years
The term impostor syndrome didn't exist when James A. Blaisdell launched his academic career at Beloit in 1903, but he definitely fit the description. “My teaching began under the strain of much difficulty,” he recalled. “I was over-timid, and one or two of the advanced classes created a serious problem for me.” Other than the occasional Sunday school class, Blaisdell had no prior experience as a teacher and there were no doubt issues rooted in his childhood experiences at home and in school, where corporal punishment of classmates was so severe that he turned inward to avoid conflict. “I often think my father would have done better if he paid me to get thrashed in school. I might have acquired more of the virtues of fearlessness and endurance and chivalrous defense of those who were subject to injustice.”
Despite his initial struggles at Beloit, he soon gained a reputation as a caring and learned teacher who challenged his students with what he called “critical and scientific” study instead of rote regurgitation to impart “a scholar's understanding of the real intention and meaning” of the Bible. When Andrew Carnegie gifted money to build a library, Blaisdell embraced the opportunity. He spent two weeks “touring the East inspecting libraries” and steadily secured funds for more books (his first successful fundraising endeavor). As new educational practices developed and fields of study rapidly advanced, he saw the library as “the inspiration and central hub of the campus” where resources had to scale as more emphasis was placed on individual research. He didn't realize it then, but he was building the foundation for his career out West.
It was not easy being James Joshua Blaisdell's son. The Beloit professor was uncompromising in his stern Calvinistic theology, forbidding little James to sing or play with other children, and threatening to punish him physically if he misbehaved at school. He also suffered from debilitating depression and spent time in sanitariums. “He so terrified me that I did not try to translate myself to him,” James A. Blaisdell recalled years later. But his father gave him a priceless gift: full access to the books that lined the study. Plato, Shakespeare, Wordsworth, and others challenged him and fueled his imagination. It was the beginning of a rich intellectual life. [Beloit College Archive Digital Collections]
He was basically a frontiersman like my grandfather. A chance to begin and to build … was his main interest.
Allen Blaisdell, Reflections: family, youth and James Blaisdell
James A. Blaisdell about 10 years into his presidency at Pomona College, shortly before turning his focus to the Group Plan. [The Metate]
While Blaisdell the academic is revered, little has been written about Blaisdell the man. But his Beloit classmates and students had a lot to say about the friend they affectionately called Jimmie.
“All the Beloiters knew [him],” wrote Victor Marriott, one of many who followed Blaisdell to Pomona College. He still had “the same rare humor, the same friendly greeting,” and despite the heavy burden of his presidency, “there is nothing that he loves more than to sit down with a friend for a chat.”
At a gathering of alumni in 1924, some who knew Jimmie the student told stories “that seemed to those graduates of this century almost sacrilegious but were, nevertheless, keenly enjoyed.” (The alumni magazine did not elaborate.) [Blaisdell, The Story of a Life]
Blaisdell was adept at navigating the administrative landscape and getting results at Beloit, where he forged an excellent relationship with President Edward Dwight Eaton. Professor Theodore R. Etecus praised Blaisdell's deft touch. “He is a pretty good man to have around when the faculty gets into a tangle. … He generally knows what he wants and [doesn't] hurt people's feelings to get it.” But perhaps the quality that Etecus found most endearing was, “He never talks as long as some of the faculty.”
Blaisdell was also a gifted public speaker who could both inspire and read an audience — skills he employed with great success throughout his time in Claremont. “He did it by understatement and by sometimes reaching with his hands and not talking at all,” recalled Caroline Bennett Fogle, a member of the first class to graduate from Scripps College and later a trustee. “We always felt he was half-fox and half-imagination.”
The President's house at Pomona College, built in 1900, with young Barbara Blaisdell in front. This American Foursquare style home is the oldest presidential residence still in use in California. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
The building of a college is like the building of a cathedral. Each is possible only by the faith, idealism, and sacrifice of a multitude.
James A. Blaisdell quoted in Granite and Sagebrush.
Mabel Shaw Bridges Hall of Music, now known as Little Bridges, opened in June 1915. Appleton and Amelia Bridges donated $100,000 (about $3 million today) in memory of their daughter, a gifted music student who died in 1907. Author and architect Charles Moore called the building "Myron Hunt's masterpiece." Bridges Auditorium, or Big Bridges, opened in 1932 (courtesy of a $650,000 Bridges gift) as the first official consortial building. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
Fall 1912
Blaisdell had requested that the inauguration be postponed after he and his family arrived in Claremont the previous year to allow him to focus on an urgent matter: The college was $150,000 in debt (nearly $5 million today). Blaisdell, who had no experience as a major fundraiser, got to work, launching a whirlwind effort that some called The Campaign of the Crisis. In three months, the debt had been erased. And he was just getting started.
A year after shoring up Pomona College's sagging finances, James A. Blaisdell turned to a much more ambitious project, the Million Dollar Campaign. (That would be $32 million today.) Things moved swiftly, fueled by Blaisdell's sometimes self-effacing, sometimes eloquent ability to inspire support. In addition to the Bridges' gift of $100,000, the citizens of Claremont provided nearly $100,000, alumni pledged over $40,000, Nathan V. Blanchard provided two $50,000 endowments, and George Marston pledged $50,000 to be used "as the trustees may deem fit." But a smaller gift that could have been a footnote had the greatest impact. The donor? Ellen Browning Scripps.
Meet the Blaisdells
James A. Blaisdell was 12 when he met Lena Florence "Dollie" Carrier at school in Beloit, Wisconsin. "She quickly took possession of all my boyish fancies and affections. … From that day on, I held her in the secret places of my heart." They married in 1892 and had three sons and a daughter before they arrived in Claremont. All four graduated from Claremont High School, and Paul and Allen went on to Pomona College. Blaisdell also cherished another member of the family — one who followed him around campus and cheered him up during difficult times — "our little dog Midget, whose radiant and unfailing devotion blest us for 13 years. Her grave is still sacred ground in our yard at the Claremont home." That home is today's Blaisdell House on 10th Street, across from the DesCombes Family Quad.
The Blaisdell family: Florence, Barbara, Paul, Allen, James Brooks, and another important member of the family, Midget. One of the beloved is buried behind the Blaisdell House.
It is for the joy of the giving that I do this, [knowing] that it is well done
Ellen Browning Scripps in letter to James A. Blaisdell in 1914
She had the resources and the passion, but she was no pushover. [J.C. Harper, Ellen Browning Scripps]
December 1914
In his memoir, “The Story of a Life,” James A. Blaisdell reflects on the countless people who helped Pomona College grow into a renowned academic institution. He mentions faculty and colleagues, as well as “day laborers, gardeners, house mothers, janitors, [and] cooks” whose contributions were often overlooked. And, of course, he thanks the benefactors whose support proved pivotal. “Five of the great were rich both in spiritual and material things,” he says, but curiously he adds, “I shall not write their names here.”
There is little doubt that Ellen Browning Scripps topped the list. Blaisdell first met her in-person in 1914 at a Christmas concert at Bishop Joseph H. Johnson's school in La Jolla, where he asked her to fund a guest lectureship in Johnson's name thatwould supplement the college curriculum. She pledged $25,000 and later thanked Blaisdell for his letter, which “sank deeply into my heart and will serve for my encouragement for many days.” Their visit in La Jolla was one of the few times they met in person. Their relationship rested instead on their powerful correspondence.
An erudite man of the people
Episcopal Bishop Joseph Horsfall Johnson arrived in Southern California in1896 just as Los Angeles was beginning its ascent as a metropolis and cultural magnet. A spiritual leader, scholar, and educator, he quickly became one of the region's civic leaders — someone both well-spoken and friendly who people gravitated to and listened to. “The bishop had an extraordinary ability to make and keep friends,” W. Bertrand Stevens said in his biography.Among those friends were Ellen Browning Scripps and James A. Blaisdell.
Johnson's knowledge of global educational institutions aided Blaisdell in creating the Group Plan for the Claremont Colleges, leaving a lasting impact on generations of students. The March 1919 issue of the Pomona College Quarterly praised him as “an executive of ability, a public-spirited citizen, a leader among men.” Blaisdell said Johnson “could always be relied upon for his presence and advice. … and to his personal friendship and support I owe a profound debt."
Joseph Horsfall Johnson, the first Episcopal Bishop of Los Angeles, served nearly 30 years on Pomona College's Board of Trustees and played a significant role in the development of Claremont Colleges as a founding member of the Board of Fellows. [Pomona College Quarterly Magazine]
We have been able to bring to Pomona, representatives from Columbia, Yale, Harvard, and other notable institutions … making for the rapid growth of the College.
James A. Blaisdell in a letter to Ellen Browning Scripps in 1919
In the faces of children she saw the potential for a new world.
Molly McClain, Ellen Browning Scripps: New Money and American Philanthropy
Ellen Browning Scripps believed in people — and she invested in them. [Ella Strong Denison Library]
Ellen Browning Scripps would have transcended any era. As Professor Molly McClain shows in her excellent biography, Scripps was accomplished, influential, unpretentious, and almost painfully modest. She was devoted to family and friends and loved children. She finished college at a time few women did, though she had to settle for a certificate because women were not granted degrees. She also had a keen sense of the newspaper business, helping her older brother launch a publishing empire in Detroit and later doing the same for her younger brother in Cleveland, which led to her introduction to J.C Harper, who would become her lawyer and close advisor.
Though she left the church because it opposed female participation, she read the Bible and helped fund the building of several churches. In La Jolla, when her sister Virginia went on trips, Ellen let the maid go on vacation and took care of things herself. McClain writes, “She rarely slept in her bedroom, preferring an old wire-woven cot that she placed on the west porch for the sake of the stars.”
Ellen Browning Scripps lived on her own terms.
Glorious sunshine, beautiful views, high intellectual aspirations and inspirations
Ellen Browning Scripps in a letter to Eliza Virginia Scripps, 1921
Poet, historian, and activist Edith Parker in her dorm room at Sumner Hall, circa 1903. The converted hotel survived over two decades of close calls from fires caused by kerosene lamps, wood stoves, lightbulbs, curling irons, and botched chemistry experiments. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
February 22, 1921
By 1922-23, women would outnumber men at Pomona College, 432 to 346. Blaisdell asked Scripps to fund a new “Woman's Campus” to replace the "constant fire peril" of the wood-framed Sumner Hall. She provided $110,000 anonymously, while Trustee C.E. Harwood contributed $50,000. Harwood Court, which housed 135 students, opened in 1920.”
Scripps, then 85, traveled from La Jolla to Claremont to attend the 10th anniversary celebration of Blaisdell's presidency and dedicate Harwood Court. Blaisdell had suggested naming it Scripps Campus for Women, but J.C. Harper reminded Blaisdell that "publicity is distasteful to Miss Scripps."
The Luxury That Scripps Learned to Love
Ellen Browning Scripps grew up when transportation meant a horse and buggy. After her horse Prince died, she relied on trains and buses, but when she turned 80, her brother E.W. Scripps bought her a chauffeur-driven Pierce-Arrow limo, which she used to take people to the polls on election day and ferry friends to the theater.
After spraining her ankle exiting the limo in 1922, her nephew and J.C. Harper converted it into an ambulance for use by a hospital and replaced it with a Rolls-Royce. Scripps was furious. “Mr. Harper has done many things which have grievously annoyed me; but I have excused him on the ground of his lacking the sense of understanding individualities as well as being the possessor of good intentions (!).”
When the Rolls arrived in June 1923, she found it "all too comfortable and too beautiful, and too luxurious!" — but she was grateful. At age 90, she took her final trip to Yosemite with friends. Soon afterward, she suffered a heart attack. “I don't mind dying,” she wrote, “but life is just beginning to be so interesting.”
Ellen Browning Scripps with her Rolls-Royce limousine in Yosemite, 1927. [La Jolla Historical Society]
Scripps anonymously helped fund Harwood Court, an unprecedented contribution to women's education in Southern California for the time. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
Blaisdell had found a kindred spirit in Scripps through their shared dedication to advancing higher education, and he admired her unwavering commitment to fund ambitious projects. “You have made me believe that whatever it costs, you prize the cognizance of large undertakings,” he wrote. A few months later, Scripps would affirm their bond when Blaisdell shared his grand vision for the future.
I am deeply interested in what President Blaisdell is planning.
Ellen Browning Scripps in 1924 [Molly McClain, Ellen Browning Scripps: New Money and American Philanthropy]
The Group Plan
Chapter 4
Were we to be left behind?
James A. Blaisdell in his address to combined boards of The Claremont Colleges, 1953
After graduating, Pomona College students—like those pictured above—had to hit the road to find graduate programs. Of the first thousand Pomona graduates between 1894 and 1919, an "exceedingly high average" of 53 percent pursued graduate degrees, the vast majority at institutions outside of Claremont. [Honnold/Mudd Special Collections]
Master's Degrees awarded
In the 16 years preceding the establishment of Claremont Colleges as a dedicated graduate school, Pomona College awarded an average of five Master's degrees per year. In its first 16 years, Claremont Colleges would award an average of 33 per year.
Pomona College (1912-1928)
81
Claremont Colleges (1929 - 1945)
521
March 1921
After securing financial stability for Pomona College, Blaisdell turned his focus to reorganizing and expanding the academic offerings in 1911. By 1915, the undergraduate curriculum had been solidified.
From that time on the chief emphasis has been … the establishment of real graduate work.
George Sumner, The Development of the Curriculum featured in The Pomona College Quarterly Magazine in 1921
As industrialization and technological advances reshaped society, demand for specialized knowledge and advanced degrees grew dramatically. Pomona College and others across the nation felt the "constant pressure to offer graduate work," according to Ernest J. Jaqua who was then dean of Pomona College.
However, Pomona's self-imposed 750-student cap made it impossible to meet the rising demand for graduate programs and the college risked falling behind.
An innovative solution was imperative.
It was now those with advanced degrees who held significant societal influence.
James A. Blaisdell in his address to combined boards of The Claremont Colleges
A small college… a large university… In the United States there was no third alternative.
Robert J. Bernard in An Unfinished Dream
Enrollment was highly competitive at Pomona College and the graduating class size was typically well under 100 prior to 1921. Alumni felt a strong sense of community and pride, a double-edged sword when their children were denied admission due to enrollment caps, and they were left "clamoring at the door." [Honnold/Mudd Special Collections]
Summer 1922
In 1915, Pomona College limited freshman enrollment to preserve the quality education found only at an intimate liberal arts institution. By the early 1920s, it was rejecting two-thirds of applicants despite the total enrollment cap being raised to 750.
The Board was “largely made up of graduates of Pomona when it was much smaller,” who “absolutely refused to increase the number of students” to preserve the small college they fondly remembered. Many Pomona College alumni would later challenge the concept of the Group Plan, believing the arrival of Claremont Colleges and Scripps College would drain resources and dilute the reputation of their alma mater.
Inspired by the design of Thomas Jefferson's University of Virginia, Marston Quadrangle became the serene nexus of the Pomona College campus upon completion around 1922. If a group that held the "Little Pomona" view had their way, the college might not have significantly expanded its footprint beyond this.
Meanwhile, Blaisdell faced a daunting decision. "We could insist on staying small and doing nothing more about it, or we could yield to the pressures of mass education … or perhaps we could do something better," Robert J. Bernard wrote later.
In 1922, Blaisdell sent Bernard, then his young aide, on a fact-finding trip to study educational models. The University of Toronto's system impressed Bernard because it “embodied the principal features of the English universities at Oxford and Cambridge — a cluster of small, independent colleges having the advantage of a university library, laboratories, and other central facilities." The concept of the Group Plan was starting to take form.
Robert J. Bernard
Joseph B. Platt, the eighth president of CGU and founding president of Harvey Mudd College, said Robert J. Bernard, “more than any other one person, built the Claremont Colleges.” An English major, Bernard graduated cum laude in 1917 and went to work for Blaisdell as his handpicked aide. “I clearly recall the day soon after joining Dr. Blaisdell when he told me that the abilities he valued most were initiative and ingenuity.”
Bernard did not disappoint. He served the Claremont Colleges for 45 years, playing a vital role in the establishment of four of them, before retiring as president of CGU in 1963. Bernard also wrote the most extensive and authoritative account of the history of the Claremont Colleges, An Unfinished Dream, taking very little credit for his deep involvement. This intentional oversight was amended by his daughter, Frances Bernard Drake, who wrote Two Men and An Idea which chronicled Blaisdell and Bernard's great accomplishments together.
Blaisdell, who considered Bernard more than a trusted colleague — perhaps even a fourth son — wrote him in retirement to express “the deep thanks I really have in my heart for you ... and for your constant kindness covering now so many years.”
Robert J. Bernard Pomona College senior yearbook photo. Metate, 1918.
In this way I should hope to preserve the inestimable personal values of the small college while securing the facilities of the great university.
James A. Blaisdell letter to Ellen Browning Scripps / October 3, 1923
The greatest danger that we face.
James A. Blaisdell in a letter to J.C. Harper in 1923
Aerial view of Claremont circa 1924, where the population within a 60-mile radius doubled between 1920 and 1926. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
I remember well going one evening to the heights overlooking the stretch of land which we did not then possess. …It was on that spot and in that hour that I determined to risk the effort.
Natalie Joy Stromberg Ward, James Arnold Blaisdell
August 1923
"Ever since I came here, my effort has been for land-land-land." James A. Blaisdell had a vision, but he knew it might be little more than that without one key ingredient. Claremont's population had nearly doubled between 1920 and 1926, and each new home or business in the broad area around Pomona College threatened that vision.
Major swaths of vacant land — 50 acres east of Dartmouth Avenue, 250 acres north of Foothill Boulevard, and other choice parcels — were at stake. “Day and night I have been in distress as I see the great opportunity slipping away,” he wrote to J.C. Harper. “It is much less possible now than two years ago, and daily it is getting more difficult." Trustees and friends stepped in to buy properties, but Blaisdell knew he had to win someone's confidence to turn the tide, and that depended on Harper.
J.C. Harper
It is ironic that CGU's best-known building is named for someone who preferred later in his career to remain in the shadows. Jacob Chandler Harper, a graduate of Cincinnati Law School, began his career as an outspoken journalist who took on politicians, supported the underprivileged, and promoted race relations at a time when the Klan was again stirring to life. He was described as "a friend of all men" with "the highest integrity" who "knew nothing whatever about quitting" and possessed "a wit that flashed instantaneously, and a flair for pungent phrasing."
He became general counsel for the Scripps newspaper empire in 1883 and in 1912, he declined the nomination for governor of Ohio, preferring to stay in journalism and "fight the bosses and the ruling class." In 1916, he moved to California where he provided unflinching support for Ellen as her lawyer and advisor while quietly looking out for her best interests.
While acting as “Miss Scripps' representative” in the development of the Group Plan, he established his own legacy, serving as a founding member on the board of Scripps College and the Board of Fellows of Claremont Colleges from 1925 until his death in 1939. Harper received a book from Ellen Browning Scripps shortly before her passing with the following inscription: “To Mr. J.C. Harper, wisest of counsellors, firmest of friends, through many years of appreciation and devoted affection.”
J.C. Harper (his last name wasn't Hall) provided invaluable insight and counsel before and during the consortium's formative years. [San Diego History Center]
It is now or never. To save the needed land [will] guarantee that Southern California will one day have one of the great educational institutions of America.
James A. Blaisdell in a letter to Ellen Browning Scripps on October 3, 1923
I was a land speculator, knowing I might either be viewed as a fool or a prophet.
James A. Blaisdell in his address to combined boards of Claremont Colleges
Total Assessed Land Value in Los Angeles County
In the 13 years since Since Blaisdell's arrival in 1910, land in Los Angeles County had risen nearly 400% in assessed value by 1923. This rapid growth happened despite a state-mandated 40% increase in 1908, when the Board of Equalization intervened to correct widespread undervaluation by counties that had kept assessments artificially low to ease taxes, attract settlers, and shield landowners from steep hikes during the real estate boom.
Data source: Chart circa 1923 in the Wheeler Scrapbook Collection [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
I do not believe I can put a considerable portion of my estate to better use.
Ellen Browning Scripps as quoted in J.C. Harper's memorandum, Purchase of Additional Land
Indian Hill was once home to Indigenous peoples who thrived in the region long before the arrival of Spanish missionaries, Mexican land grantees, and American settlers. Tragically, epidemics such as smallpox in the 19th century contributed to the devastating decline of local Native communities. In 1871, the land was claimed by W.T. "Tooch" Martin, the first known Anglo-American settler in what would become Claremont. This mesa-like plateau, rising nearly 100 feet above the surrounding terrain, was later purchased by Ellen Browning Scripps, who donated it to Claremont Colleges for the purposes of education and environmental preservation. Today, it is home to the California Botanic Garden. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
I believe that I am speaking the simple truth when I say that you are laying the foundations of a Woman's College and of a Graduate College for all this region for all the coming years...
James A. Blaisdell in a letter to Ellen Browning Scripps on January 1924
January 1924
The Scripps gift added 250 contiguous acres north of Foothill Boulevard, but Blaisdell knew that the “checkerboard” of privately held land south of Foothill between College and Columbia was essential to realizing his vision. Acquiring the land — some vacant and some developed as tidy bungalows — required ingenuity, a solid business plan of borrowing and credit, and a Blaisdell-esque ability to inspire philanthropy.
“At great personal sacrifice” (Blaisdell's words) and on very generous terms covered by the Scripps gift, Pomona College graduate Charlotte Thomas Palmer sold a large tract south of Foothill Boulevard, which is now part of the Harvey Mudd College campus. Other members of the community, many of them academics, pledged to donate or sell their land and homes. This moment was decades in the making — yet there was still more work to be done. In 1927, Blaisdell and Bernard created The Story of a College Campus, a fundraising brochure that made the case for $600,000 to purchase the remainder of the land east of College Avenue, intended for “central buildings and for new colleges” including what is now the CGU campus. The estate of Professor Charles Cummings Stearns and his wife, Sophia, provided a slice of the land (where their home stood) that became Harper Hall.
The toil and labor and expense … have been beyond all description.
James A. Blaisdell, The Story of a College Campus
It's an understatement that college news dominated the front page of the Claremont Courier on this Thursday in February. Blaisdell wrote a message to explain the “educational purposes” behind the massive land purchase and assuage any concerns of the Claremont community, assuring there was “no ambition to extend … beyond the bounds already acquired.”
The College at the Crossroads
William B. Munro, address at Pomona College Commencement / 1925
Blaisdell's concept of the Group Plan was brought to life in an inspiring and ambitious architectural rendering by Jamieson and Spearl of St. Louis. Inspired by Oxford and Cambridge, the firm designed a layout of colleges grouped around shared facilities, such as a central library and laboratories, with the goal of fostering both individuality and collaboration. The plan, spanning over a mile in each direction provided the impetus to bring to life “the great future which is in store for Southern California." [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
March 1925
The landmark events following Scripps' monumental gift in 1924 unfolded haphazardly. Blaisdell had announced the massive land purchases — nearly a decade in the making — a year before he presented the first formal proposal for the Group Plan to the Pomona College board in March 1925.
For a visionary fundraiser and highly accomplished college president, Blaisdell's proposal for the central college was shockingly vague, offering no clear provisions for governance or a financial model for shared resources within the group. More of a rough outline than a plan, it proved to be a PR failure that forced Blaisdell to constantly explain and re-explain the role of Claremont Colleges for the next decade. The proposal was contentiously debated among the Pomona College constituency — a debate later echoed in Trustee William Munro's June commencement address, "The College at the Crossroads."
... there were controversies almost from the beginning and some of them were bitter.
William W. Clary, Oral History
In an attempt to remedy this, Blaisdell had Jamieson and Spearl produce an architectural rendering titled “The Group Plan, The Pomona Colleges.” The design “inspired enthusiasm for the concept” while serving as evidence that the name Claremont Colleges had not yet been decided. Perhaps “The Pomona Colleges” was suggested at this point to pacify the Pomona alumni who, once highly supportive, were now Blaisdell's strongest opponents.
Though it lacked a constitution or operating agreement, The Group Plan was ultimately approved by the board in September. Though the plan raised more questions than it answered, it did, however, clear a legal path for Robert Bernard's mad dash to incorporate Claremont Colleges on October 14 just as Blaisdell — still the acting president of Pomona — departed for a yearlong sabbatical. Until then, Scripps' land gift had remained in trust because no appropriate legal entity existed to receive it.
The first board meeting of Claremont Colleges took place in November — without Blaisdell and still without an operating agreement for the group. (Spoiler: That didn't happen until 1942). Seven of the first nine fellows were also members of the Pomona College board, ensuring competing interests and conflict — a logical rebuke to Blaisdell's idealistic belief that everyone would work for the common good. For the next thirteen years, a majority of the board would be affiliated with either Pomona or Scripps.
You need to get away.
J.C. Harper in a letter to James A. Blaisdell on April 1, 1925
Blaisdell thought that acquiring land would be the most critical part of achieving his vision. He later explained that The Group Plan was intentionally open-ended because he wanted people to collaborate “in a spirit of democratic comradeship” rather than view it as his mandate or as a self-serving attempt to position himself as chancellor of the group.
As a result, the turbulent year after his triumphant announcement of Scripps’ gift in 1924 took a heavy toll. While his sabbatical was widely publicized as a research trip to study leading academic institutions in postwar Europe, J.C. Harper had suggested to Blaisdell in April that, much like his presidential redecessors, his health was at risk — advising him, “you need to get away.”
Before the dawn of the Christian era, two thousand years ago, the torch of learning was borne aloft by two ancient universities, at Antioch and at Athens.
From them it passed to the universities at Rome and Alexandria.
They handed it, during the Middle Ages, to Padua and Paris, whence it was carried across the Channel to Oxford, and Cambridge.
Oxford and Cambridge, in their turn, provided the founders of Harvard, Yale and other colleges of Colonial America.
Finally, in the nineteenth century, the heralds of truth and of light spread themselves across the face of the whole continent.
William B. Munro, The College at the Crossroads
Blaisdell's Sabbatical Year
Chapter 5
The mission will involve a year of research on this continent and abroad.
Letter from the Pomona College Board of Trustees in October 1925
The invitation for Blaisdell’s farewell dinner at the Biltmore Hotel in downtown Los Angeles celebrated his upcoming research trip and noted the attendance of a recently knighted British educator. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
October 1925
The Pomona College Board of Trustees understood the monumental investment and world-changing potential of The Group Plan and granted Blaisdell a yearlong sabbatical to promote the Group Plan idea on the East Coast, a full circle moment in American education. From there, he would head to Europe to research the educational models of the most distinguished institutions. Traveling Europe with his wife Lena and daughter Barbara also provided a chance for Blaisdell to recharge his batteries after an intense, nonstop 15 years as president of Pomona College.
Shortly before his departure, the board organized a farewell dinner attended by local dignitaries at the Biltmore Hotel in downtown Los Angeles. “As Robert J. Bernard hoped, the dinner gave wings to the whole future plan,” said E. Wilson Lyon, Pomona’s sixth president, in a history of the consortium. Two weeks shy of her 89th birthday, Scripps was unable to attend but sent a letter announcing a gift of Detroit Evening News stock valued at $500,000 (more than $9 million today) as the initial endowment for the Scripps College for Women.
“The dinner in every sense was a heartwarming occasion.” Bernard noted. “It brought ... to the larger metropolitan community a spirited interpretation of the unique developments at Claremont.”
The Ivy League connection
America’s oldest colleges and universities had a significant presence at the Claremont Colleges in their early years. Charles Sumner, founding trustee of Pomona College, was a Yale graduate, and Ernest J. Jaqua, a Harvard alumnus, served as Pomona's dean and acting president during Blaisdell’s sabbatical before becoming the first president of Scripps College. In addition, for several years Pomona participated in a program that brought Harvard faculty to Pomona for a year and sent Pomona faculty to Harvard. The Congregational Church connection was also strong. Harvard and Yale trained Congregational clergy in their early years, and Pomona College’s founding is intricately tied to Congregational Church leaders, who drew up articles of incorporation that referred to “a college of the New England type.” From the humble beginning of a small, rented cottage in Pomona, few would have predicted that a president of that college would one day return to New England to present a groundbreaking model in American education.
In 1925, Pomona College had eighty total faculty. Ten were Harvard alumni, nine of whom are pictured here. [Harvard Alumni Bulletin Vol. 28 No.13 December 31, 1925]
The Biltmore Hotel
Built to rival premier hotels in New York, London, and Paris, the Los Angeles Biltmore (as it was known then) was the largest hotel west of Chicago when it opened in 1923. Its design paid homage to grand European palaces, reflected in its $10 million price tag (more than $150 million today). A “beacon of elegance and sophistication,” the arrival of the Biltmore was symbolic of Blaisdell’s vision of the role the rapidly developing US West would play in shaping history. The Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences was founded at the Biltmore in 1927, less than two years after Blaisdell’s sendoff dinner, and in 1932 Los Angeles became front and center on the world stage as host of the Summer Olympics.
Prior to hosting Blaisdell’s sendoff dinner in October of 1925, the Biltmore was the meeting site of The Friends of the Claremont Colleges — an organization of prominent local educators, philanthropists, and civic leaders. This was the result of a focused effort that was started in the early 1920s by Blaisdell and Pomona College leadership to raise more awareness (and money) and strengthen ties with the broader civic and business community of Los Angeles.
The music room of the Biltmore Hotel, pictured in 1934, would become the campaign headquarters for John F. Kennedy at the DemocraticNational Convention in 1960. Eventually, the Music Room was converted into the lobby, most famously shown in the 1984 film, Ghostbusters.
He didn’t want it called the Oxford plan. ... It was essentially American in its concept
Allan Blaisdell interview, The Claremont Graduate School Oral History Program
Little more than a week after the incorporation of Claremont Colleges, Blaisdell was in Washington hosting a banquet to announce the adoption of The Group Plan to a group of “prominent eastern and western educators and Pomona alumni.” The announcement, which also shared information about the newly formed Board of Fellows, was made simultaneously in Claremont, according to an article in the Claremont Courier. The headline proclaimed the Oxford model as the basis of the plan, a comparison that Blaisdell would later come to regret.
The Group Plan, as it was officially known by Blaisdell and his peers in Claremont, was regularly referred to externally as the Oxford plan. The Oxford comparison certainly put Claremont in good company — and Blaisdell helped cement the impression by visiting Oxford during his sabbatical and proposing that Claremont was to be “somewhat on the Oxford type” — but The Group Plan for Claremont was distinctly American.
Blaisdell embraced the concept of federalism (a United Colleges of Claremont, if you will), with institutions having significant independence but also cooperating and sharing certain responsibilities for the common good. In addition, California law required individual colleges to award degrees, unlike the Oxford model, and American colleges and universities almost always had a lay board of trustees to oversee administration. (At Oxford, the faculty had control, with some alumni oversight.) Blaisdell deeply admired Oxford and later in life bemoaned the Claremont Colleges’ increasing distance from it, but he never envisioned Claremont as a replica of Oxford.
Great interest everywhere — I must say enthusiasm about our plans.
James A. Blaisdell in a letter to J.C. Harper in November 1925
En route to Europe, Blaisdell visited Harvard to discuss The Group Plan with President A. Lawrence Lowell. A month later, the Harvard Alumni Bulletin praised the plan as “a promising ... plan of collegiate federalism.” [Harvard Alumni Bulletin Vol. 28 No.13 December 31, 1925]
In his autobiography, Blaisdell noted that Claremont Colleges was intended to be “a precise parallel to the United States … a single entity though made up of parts, each of which has nevertheless an integrity of its own.”
Great interest everywhere — I must say enthusiasm about our plans.
James A. Blaisdell in a letter to J.C. Harper in November 1925
En route to Europe, Blaisdell visited Harvard to discuss The Group Plan with President A. Lawrence Lowell. A month later, the Harvard Alumni Bulletin praised the plan as “a promising ... plan of collegiate federalism.” [Harvard Alumni Bulletin Vol. 28 No.13 December 31, 1925]
You can do this in California, but we are not in a position to undertake it here.
Harvard President A. Lawrence Lowell to James A. Blaisdell
Most beloved woman in Southern California.
TIME Magazine, February 1926
Two years after making front page news in the Claremont Courier, Ellen Browning Scripps was again front and center — this time on the national stage. [TIME Magazine]
February 1926
Ellen Browning Scripps became the first woman to be featured on the cover of TIME in February 1926. The wide-ranging article covers The Group Plan, though not directly referred to as such, and the founding of Pomona College. It also contains a biography of Scripps that is full of personal details and anecdotes. Though one of the wealthiest women in America, Scripps was of little notoriety by her own design. Why would TIME choose to feature her in a space that was usually reserved for people of international or at least national renown? Modest to the extreme and notably disdainful of publicity, it’s hard to imagine that Scripps would have agreed to a cover (or any) feature in the most influential magazine in the US. But if she wasn’t consulted, who planted the story and for what purpose? TIME will never tell.
The California Oxford … calls itself Claremont Colleges.
TIME Magazine, February 1926
James A. Blaisdell postcard to Ellen Browning Scripps from Geneva, Switzerland featuring the Palais Wilson, first home of the League of Nations. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collection]
March 1926
The Blaisdells’ European journey began in Paris and Northern Italy before James A. Blaisdell spent several weeks studying Swiss universities in Geneva. He also observed the League of Nations in session, which he was thrilled to see in “such [a] vivid and realistic way” during a time of "great perplexity” in the months leading up to the admission of Germany. What he witnessed in Geneva echoed developments in higher education across the continent as Germany—much like in the political sphere—was “beginning to reassume its old prestige.”
The educational map of Europe is reorganizing itself.
James A. Blaisdell in a postcard to Ellen Browning Scripps in March 1926
I doubt whether this data is going to be adequately assembled by anybody but yourself.
J.C. Harper in a letter to James A. Blaisdell in April 1926
James A. Blaisdell and his wife, Lena Carrier Blasidell, visited their daughter Barbara in Grenoble, France. A member of the French circle at Pomona College just a few years prior, Barbara was no doubt living out her Francophonic dream studying at the University of Grenoble. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
Read Blaisdell message to Scripps
Return to Image
Dear Miss Scripps: This is our view of the glorious snow-clad Alps, with the Isère flowing through the old town. Today, we have been auto-ing through ancient villages, castles, etc. It is a far cry to the new lands of California.” Gratefully, James A.B.
I have found some interesting things, but I look for the most enlightenment in England...
James A. Blaisdell letter to Ellen Browning Scripps
Two individuals put the keystone in place. One was Ellen Scripps ... The other was Colonel Seeley W. Mudd
Malcolm Douglass, Phoenix in Academe
Like Ellen Browning Scripps, Seeley W. Mudd was a self-made millionaire. He built his fortune as a mining engineer and industrial entrepreneur whose leadership and business acumen shaped significant copper and ore development projects in the United States and abroad. He earned the rank of colonel in the Army serving in the Engineer Officers Reserve Corps, where he lent his expertise to improve munitions production during World War I for a salary of $1 per year.
May 1926
James A. Blaisdell’s early fundraising not only saved Pomona College from financial ruin but also legitimized the institution and significantly raised its profile, attracting interest from magnates like Mudd and his close friend William L. Honnold. Mudd joined the board of Pomona College in 1914 and was named first Head Fellow of Claremont Colleges in December 1925. In Mudd, Blaisdell found a close friend and confidant whom he considered “indispensable” at this critical juncture.
Blaisdell was still in Europe when J.C. Harper wrote to inform him that Mudd had been diagnosed with inoperable stomach cancer, just months after being named Head Fellow. Harper, who urged Mudd to set aside college matters and focus on his heath, described the situation to Blaisdell as “hopeless.” Shortly after Harper’s letter reached Blaisdell, Mudd underwent emergency abdominal surgery for a malignant tumor (despite the inoperable diagnosis) while “speeding through Kansas” on a train to New York. He died weeks later in his hometown of St. Louis at St. Luke’s Hospital where his brother, Harvey G. Mudd, was chief surgeon.
In his will, Mudd left $1 million for the initial endowment of Claremont Colleges, laying the financial foundation for the nascent institution.
Ellen Browning Scripps was born at 5 South Molton Street in London in 1836. Her father, James Mogg Scripps, was a bookbinder, and the family lived above his shop. Although a skilled artisan, James Mogg’s business failed because he could not compete with the large workshops using newly invented bookbinding machines. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
Ellen Browning Scripps was born at 5 South Molton Street in London in 1836. Her father, James Mogg Scripps, was a bookbinder, and the family lived above his shop. Although a skilled artisan, James Mogg’s business failed because he could not compete with the large workshops using newly invented bookbinding machines. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
Letters written by Blaisdell
My dear Miss Scripps:
Mrs. Blaisdell, Barbara, and I went on our hunt this afternoon, and although we are still confused in London streets and roads, we were easily successful in locating the numbers which you gave us. We had a most cordial gracious reception from Mr. O.T. Scripps who took us over to the exact place of your birth. The whole experience was a great pleasure to us and one which we shall always hold in happy memory.
James A. Blaisdell Letter to Ellen Browning Scripps in June 1926
June 1926
At seven years old, Ellen Browning Scripps moved with her father and five siblings to the Illinois prairie following the death of her mother. Growing up in poverty, she found refuge and inspiration in the collection of “the best English literature” that her father had brought with them. More than 60 years later and 6,000 miles away in La Jolla, California, Scripps honored her London family home by giving the name South Molton Villa to her stunning new estate overlooking the Pacific Ocean. Over time, she gradually purchased adjacent land and, with the help of her sister Eliza, transformed it into a family compound.
In 1915, the original Victorian-style South Molton Villa was badly damaged by fire and replaced by a new concrete structure designed by Irving J. Gill, a pioneer of the modern movement. In her estate plans, Ellen Browning Scripps directed that the house should benefit the people of La Jolla for educational and cultural use. It is now home to the Museum of Contemporary Art San Diego. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
A full year after his leave of absence was announced in the Claremont Courier, James A. Blaisdell had finally reached Oxford. He wrote to J.C. Harper from the Abbotsford Hotel in London on the eve of his Oxford visit. [Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
Blaisdell’s year abroad, funded by Ellen Browning Scripps, gave him a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to travel through Europe with his family and conduct invaluable research on academic organization, institutional design, and campus architecture beyond the pressure of the Pomona College presidency.
But it came at a heavy price. While his plan was well received at Harvard and vindicated by his research in Europe, his absence at such a critical stage in the development of Claremont Colleges would later be cited as a key reason The Group Plan fell far short of what he envisioned.
Sumner M. Spaulding
Sumner M. Spaulding (1892–1952) was a prominent Southern California architect whose work spanned collegiate design and major civic projects. After joining James A. Blaisdell in 1925 to study European university residence halls, Spaulding translated those insights into Pomona College’s North Campus plan, including Clark Hall and the iconic Frary Dining Hall. He later contributed to iterations of the Hollywood Bowl and to the planning and architectural development of the Los Angeles County–USC Medical Center.
The inaugural dinner dance in Frary Hall marked the debut of Pomona’s new North Campus. Designed by Sumner Spaulding, the hall’s soaring barrel-vaulted ceiling, wrought-iron chandeliers, tiled floors, and dark wood paneling exemplified his California-Mediterranean style.
[Honnold/Mudd Library Special Collections]
…Cambridge last week and had rich results. We go to Oxford tomorrow A.M. My heart is full of gratitude — beyond any possibility of words.
James A. Blaisdell letter to J.C. Harper in June 1926
On High Street, Oxford, in 1929, the "dreaming spires" of the university rise above the bustle of the city as they did when Blaisdell first arrived. Beneath the distinctive skyline formed by independent colleges sharing one horizon, his own future was coming into focus.